Yesterday I held this essay. I didn’t even attempt to write it. Instead, in person and on the phone and in emails and private messages, I tried to comfort friends who were devastated by the election results in their own and other states when it came to the results from anti-marriage referenda in California, Florida, Arizona, and, perhaps the most benighted one of all, the ballot-measure passed in Arkansas that serves to deprive state-controlled children from foster-care if the foster or adoptive parents are an unmarried or “gay” couple.Â
Ya know, it’s one thing to tell me that Catherine and I aren’t going to be allowed to marry one another and have that marriage recognized by the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania; but, it’s a very mean-spirited tactic to have a ballot-proposition that refuses to place children in a home simply because that home might have lesbians, gay men or bi-sexual adults living in it. Or that those same children cannot even be adopted by an unmarried two-parent household.Â
Is this what homophobia results in? The punishment and dismissal of a child’s life to make sure that no possible “stain” attaches to the child in the minds of the neand … …. O wait, I was about to write Neanderthal  as an adjective for the yahoos in Arkansas who wrote, lobbied and campaigned for and voted for that proposition.Â
But, in actually knowing a bit about what we have discovered about Neanderthals: they buried their dead and sent with them flowers and implement gifts to the next life; they lived in community and obviously took care of one another, no doubt leaving no child to fend for itself when their parents died or were unable to care for the child, I find myself wrong to give such hating and fear-mongering human beings a name as honorable and humane as Neanderthal.
Neanderthals apparently even took in Cro-Magnon children who were orphaned, although there’s also ample evidence that suggests that Cro-Magnon peoples were the major reason for the disappearance of Neanderthals. I mean, Hell! Neanderthals understood what the morons in Arkansas cannot or will not: life trumps my personal prejudices and a child’s well-being certainly shouldn’t involve my sense that someone who cares for that child might be immoral. What base hatred and darkness must lie in my heart that I’m willing to punish children for what I am afraid are the sins of adults?Â
I’m sorry this foolishness is simply heartless and cold and deserves each of us railing as strongly as possible and doing what we can to end it. It’s almost as if Arkansas has managed to become the country’s most yokel-filled and benighted state during the past four years of “Focus on the Family,” “Americans For Truth,” and their fellow-travelers’ fear and hate-mongering diatribes about the fall of western civilization and the progress of the entire nation into hell.
Their forefathers and mothers used the same tropes, the same appeals to fear and loathing, toward persons of color as their children now use to paint LTBG-folk as monsters worthy only of fear and unreasoning hatred. These people simply deny the very morality they claim to believe in. Read Here for a perspective on that.
But, back to my friends in California, Arizona, and Florida. They’ve been legally told that most people do not think they have the civil-right of as much comfort in their lives as do those who voted for the two amendments and the one proposition. Evidently the sea-change of acceptance for the rights of same-sex couples to marry legally and so make on paper what has already been made in their lives, needs more work. It needs more “human face” placed on it, I believe.Â
Last year Rep. (Dem.) Barney Frank of Massachusetts said this to transsexuals and transgender people while removing us from his ENDA bill that would include gays:
This is a fairly recent addition to the fight, and part of the problem we face is that while there have been literally decades of education of the public about the unfairness of sexual orientation discrimination and the inaccuracy of the myths that perpetuated it, our educational efforts regarding gender identity are much less far along, and given the prejudices that exist, face a steeper climb.
At the time I was willing to use Barney as a mop-head for my kitchen mop. I mean, very easy, no? for a man who was including himself and his lover in the bill to say it couldn’t be passed if he included me? I mean, what arrogant baloney was that? Time under the mop-water would be a good lesson in humility I believed for this two-faced and privileged individual. He seemed yet another man who wants the world to kow-tow to his notion of the rightness of things and the wrongness of things.Â
A year has made some difference though. Barney gave transgender/transsexual people a perfectly good reason for our exclusion: people aren’t ready for you yet, you’ve more work to do for people to realize that you are people as well as they. That same reason I hand back to Mr. Frank and to other lesbians and gay men. We have a lot more work to do to show others that we are simply people too. Work to show them that we can raise children healthily, that our unions are as filled with love and care, perhaps even in same cases more so due to the inherent prejudices we have to overcome to maintain them, as are their own. We must show them that we deserve and long-for the recognition they give to themselves, knowing in their hearts
that they are not monsters or devil-spawn, that they are “just folks” like us, struggling in the world to reach some wholeness and peace with our lives.
The fact is I am becoming more and more certain that such examples, such a winning argument, for gay marriage cannot be made at a ballot-box. The fact is that Barack Obama’s stirring victory for the Presidency was not a one-shot effort that had no history, no giant’s shoulders on which he stood to claim his prize and a prize for people of color in this country. He stood on the shoulders of Jesse Jackson, A. Phillip Randolph, the Martin Luther Kings (Sr. & Jr.,) Rosa Parks, James Earl Jones, Bill Cosby, Nikki Giovanni, Maya Angelou, Oprah Winfrey, Thurgood Marshall, Paul Robeson, George Washington Carver, Frederick Douglass and millions of other black men and women who made it possible for 52%+ of the current electorate to recognize that the color of his skin was not the measure of his character or ability.
How was that victory won? Through the tireless efforts of people young and old who committed their energies and their bodies to meeting others, to talking in homes, on street corners, in churches and along sidewalks and in malls across the country to show others that “damn, why are we afraid of them?” That, it seems to me is the key.
It’s one thing for gay men and lesbians to win legislative and legal victories. It’s an entirely different thing for us to win the hearts and minds of other human beings when it comes to how valid and acceptable our love and hopes are in relation to their own. In order to do so we are going to have to look at our own fears, our own senses that huge mailer and media efforts to win the educational war are going to continue to fail to win us acceptance and constitutional rights without us putting human faces and human hearts out there for others to see and know.
One gay couple who live together can manage to win through the fear and loathing ingrained by priests, ministers, the moguls of the Religious Right propaganda machines that spew out their venomous hatred toward us and raise atavistic fears among others who simply do not know us as human beings.
My friends Russell and John and my friends Phyllis and Yvette were either civilized or unionized in New Jersey over the past 18 months. The High Court and Legislature there decided that civil unions with the full-benefits of “marriage” were to be the order-of-the-day in New Jersey. The daily work involved with that legal fact remains as much verbal as it does physical. The New Jersey legal framework cannot bend the Federal government to a recognition in terms of taxes and other advantages in which it prefers and privileges heterosexual marriages over gay and lesbian civil unions, no matter the state policies of New Jersey. Nor has it, in some cases, bent the corporate and company benefits rules as yet.
But, when one visits in their homes, talks to them at church, or meets them in public areas, one cannot help but see the love and devotion, the very real marriage of those couples. They are the reality of gay and lesbian unions. They place human faces for neighbors, friends and family on the validity of long-standing and deeply important recognitions of love and devotion. They do so with their lives and the reach those lives have to influence others. So too with that list of black folk above.
Thus, it seems to me that our desire to overturn Prop. 8 by legal means may be well-managed and may even win in the California Courts; the real test will be in California minds and hearts. What victory will it be to have the James Dobsons and Peter Labarberas telling all and sundry that we have won our own civil-rights through a “technicality?” The folk who already believe us to be pariahs and dangerous people when it comes to educating their children, serving as legislators and governors, as therapists, garbage-workers, police, nurses, doctors, insurance agents, store clerks, pharmacists, managers, maintenance persons, athletes, radio, cinema, music and television personalities, ministers, priests and, most importantly mothers and fathers giving love, values and comfort to our children, will not find it in their hearts to accept that we are people and so much more like them than different from them if we are unwilling to manage our own fears of them enough to reach out and be seen for who we are and how we truly live.Â
The battle for hearts and minds, for human companionship, and relationship is not won at the ballot-box first, nor in the legislative halls or the courts. Those are certainly important places to win, but the lives of real and caring people are the places those battles must be won first and foremost.
We gave money, gave time at rallies, inundated air-waves and mailboxes with “educational aids;” but, face
it, the screeds of the Mormon Church elders, the rabbis and imams, the fear-spitting images of Dobson and LaBarbera, the Bishops, Archbishops, Elders and ministers of California, Florida, Arizona and Arkansas overrode that fairly easily because what we have failed to do is to do the groundwork, the hard work of allowing people across the country to get to know us to begin to understand that what moves us is not demonology but relationship and humanity.
Please take the time to view these fine blogs ( http://www.pamshouseblend.com/frontPage.do  http://www.bilerico.com/ Â
http://feministing.com/about.htm http://lesbian.pro/ http://www.feministe.us/blog/  http://bitchmagazine.org/and follow links there to other LTBG blogs and sites.) Discover people just like you, except we are gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender and you may not be any of those. But, what you’ll find is other human beings who struggle with their lives and the value they are given by others. The differences are small and become inconsequential when you actually learn to see us as our hearts are. We have never been the demons some cast us as, we have always been your neighbors and friends, the teacher in your childrens’ classrooms, the cop in your town, and the people in the pews around you at Mass, synagogue, temple and prayer.Â
It’s time we get to know one another and discover that sheer and unrelenting hatred and fear are the bogeymen that keep us chained, alone and isolated in a world that is rich in promise and relationship. It’s time we reach out to you and do the hard work of showing you other human beings instead of fearful caricatures held out to you by those who thrive in alienation and their own base and groundless fears. That is not religion or humanity; that is the evil we must work to alleviate and change by showing ourselves and the contents of our characters to you, those who have never met us and those we have been fearful of meeting for the safety of our lives.
The lesson of the Obama campaign for the LTBG is the battle is won on the ground, not in the media. It’s up to us, lesbians, gay-men, bi-sexuals and men and women of transgender presentations and transsexual histories to get out and the ground and meet our neighbors, show them the base fact that we are deserving, loving, caring and human, just as they are.Â


Recent Comments